Shake And Slate Synthetic Composite Roofing

Costs, Pros and Cons

Slate and clay tiles for roofing have a long history and a beauty that is unique. However, they come at a notoriously high cost. Asphalt shingles are often used as an alternative, becoming the number one roofing material in North America. But wouldn’t it be nice if there was another option that had the beauty and durability of slate. or even cedar shake, with lesser cost? There is! Synthetic shingles.

Advantages of Synthetic Shingles

  • Lighter / easier to install than natural counterparts
  • Resistant to mold, mildew, fungus, rot or insect infestation
  • Holds up to weather variation, extremely well. Is hail resistant, can handle extreme temperature changes, and can withstand up to 180 mph winds before it tears off.
  • Needs very little maintenance (annual cleaning at most)
  • Is not fragile, or can be walked on (unlike natural slate)
  • Eco-friendly, the base material is recyclable
  • Oh yeah, and it’s fireproof
Large wooden home with shingle roof
Large stone home

Disadvantages of Synthetic Shingles

The disadvantages are really more like words of caution. Cost would be the most well known disadvantage as asphalt shingles rule the market and as already noted, are about half the cost to install. But here are some other considerations:

  • Synthetic shingles have been on the market since 1993, so they don’t have the track record of their natural peers. Warranties therefore must be taken with a grain of salt
  • Also, it isn’t well known how the color in the material will fade over time, but so far they are known to hold up well
  • Usually a home roofing job needs to pass with local building codes, and because this product is relatively new, it might not even be included in such codes or could be forbidden. Likely not the case, but still a consideration.

Costs and Value

For synthetic composite shingles, shakes, tiles and slates, a fair price range is $5.50 to $9.50 per sq. ft. installed. The price will likely be higher in densely populated coastal areas with high costs of doing business including labor cost. With that in mind, the total projected cost of composite roofing installed would be about one third to one half the price of installing natural slate, and roughly twice the cost of installing asphalt shingles. And, it is nearly the same price as installing a cedar shake roof. The difference though is that synthetic roofing materials are lighter and easier to install than other materials, plus they are actually as durable as stone!

Did you know? Total Costs Installed are largely determined by the choice of materials, location, shape and slope of the roof, and quality, reputation and experience of the installer.

Durability and longevity provide enormous advantage when it comes to the return on investment (ROI). Did you know? Asphalt shingles and cedar shakes are going to go through a minimum of three life cycles on the same sized roof that a synthetic shingle occupies. Generally, synthetic shingles will carry a 50 plus year warranty. Yet, this is not the only advantage (see below). We estimate a 70 to 80 percent ROI with synthetic roofing products, which likely holds true, if not better for fake or simulated slate.

There are really two primary types synthetic roofing materials; There’s the type that mimics slate (natural stone), and the type that looks like cedar shake (wood). Generally, manufacturers of the synthetic material will stick to one type over the other. Barrington Roof Doctors can provide you with both synthetic slate also known as fake slate, and simulated synthetic shakes.

Technically, synthetic roofing material is a polymer-based composition, or simply put a mixture of rubber and plastic. It may vary slightly in composition so as to engineer a proprietary blend (allowing for proper branding). To form it as slate or shingles, molds are used. Historically, shake and shingles are not the same thing, and to achieve the exact look (of shake) or (slate shingles), different molds are used. Either way, the final appearance is hard to distinguish from the natural material. Up close, perhaps the discerning eye can tell the difference, but from curbside, it would be imperceptible.


The beauty, durability, and modest cost makes synthetic shingles one of the options to consider for any roofing job. Stone slate roofing has held the reins as cream of the crop of all roofing materials, and now there’s an item in the market that holds up just as well, possibly better, and for much less cost.

Call Today to Enjoy Expert Craftsmanship

Contact Barrington Roof Doctors, Inc., today for hitch-free roof repair and installation. We are the roofing contractor to trust for a roof that will last decades. Call (847) 404-9801 to book your free inspection in or around Barrington, IL.

Connect with Us

Check out our social pages or our reviews page for updates on what we have going on!

Contact Us

  • Barrington Roof Doctors, Inc.
  • North Barrington, IL 60010
  • Monday - Friday: 7:00am - 5:00pm
  • Saturday: 9:00am - 2:00pm
Scroll to Top